Should I, or not?

Cover of "The Trumpet of the Swan (full c...

Cover of The Trumpet of the Swan (full color)

I’m not adding this book to my list of what I’ve read this year, because I’m missing 30 pages of it (to be precise, pp121-152 repeat, and then the text skips straight to p185 in my copy), but I think I’ve read enough of it to discuss here anyway.

The Trumpet of the Swan by E. B. White

I’ve read Charlotte’s Web several times as a child, and heard of Stuart Little, but I hadn’t come across this E. B. White book before. It’s the story of a boy who loves nature (Sam) who on one of his regular camping trips with his father sees a pair of Trumpeter Swans nesting, and who keeps an eye on them as much as he can. More specifically it’s the tale of Louis, one of the cygnets, who is lacking a voice. His parents consider this quite a serious handicap, since a male Trumpeter Swan attracts his mate with his call, and so his father undertakes to obtain a trumpet for him, while Louis and Sam find some even more unorthodox means of communication for him.

As in Charlotte’s Web, the animal stars generally understand human speech and some experts understand human culture in great detail, even though the humans do not understand animal conversation. Those with such expertise find ways to interact with humans to get what they and their family/friends need. In this book the interaction is much more extensive and two way, with the animal stars deviating much further from expected species behaviour.

I generally enjoyed the tale, although I found it a little more twee than I expected. If it comes up I’d like to get a complete copy for DD when she’ll be old enough to appreciate chapter stories.


Tags: , , , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “Should I, or not?”

  1. Yelena Says:

    Have you read The Boxcar Children? This is the Rocket Boy’s latest obsession and he listens to it for hours (audio book). You’ve probably written about it before (I just haven’t had the time to look through the archives).

    • kaet Says:

      No, I hadn’t heard of them. I’ll see if I can try them out, though, with that recommendation! (Oh, and if you do want to look for something, I put a search box at the top right of the blog’s home page.)

  2. thiskidreviews Says:

    I really liked the Trumpet of the Swan, my first grade reading teacher gave it to me as a gift at the end of the year. I have read it several times. I like EB White’s other books too. I agree with Yelena -the Box Car Children is a great series they are great adventure and mystery stories without being violent or too scary. I would also recommened “The Wind in the Willows” by Kenneth Grahame.

    • kaet Says:

      I’ve ordered one of the early Boxcar Children books on Yelena’s recommendation, and am pleased to get another vote for the series. I’ll report back once I’ve read it.

      I like The Wind in the Willows a lot too, and actually reread and reviewed it a few months ago.

  3. Swan Soup « wildchow Says:

    […] Should I, or not? ( […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: